I used Tableau to create the following graph of the positive/negative difference relating to goals for/against based on team averages with/without that player in the starting line-up that season.
Qualifying players were in a team’s starting line-up between 4 and 34 times to create a ‘sensible’ average difference. For more information on the methodology click here.
Use the version linked to below and hover over data points to see which player each star represents. NB. positive numbers are good for both goals for and goals conceded.